Protests against police brutality continue around the country, but not everyone who wants can participate. Whether immunocompromised, living with someone in a high-risk group for COVID-19, or simply too far away to attend a protest, people around the world have found their own way to engage: live streams.
Leigh Wallace, an 18-year-old in Mississippi, goes through chemotherapy every other week to treat Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The treatment hasn’t affected her immune system as much as it has other patients, Wallace said, but her parents are wary of allowing her around other people, even friends. While treatable, Hodgkin’s lymphoma limits the body’s ability to fight infection. The number of new coronavirus cases is increasing in many states, and the world is bracing itself for a “second wave,” expected to hit this autumn.
But Wallace couldn’t just sit at home while her peers marched against police brutality. Her parents have a tight grip on her bank account, so she couldn’t donate to a bail fund or community organization. While she signed petitions pushing for prosecution for officers and advocating for defunding law enforcement, Wallace wanted to be more involved.
“News stations and YouTubers can take the footage and later edit them to fit their personal agenda.”
She began watching Instagram live streams of the protests to stay informed. In a Twitter DM, she said that because she was viewing raw, unedited footage, she could get a clearer picture of what’s actually happening. Watching the protests live allows viewers to see police using disturbing force against peaceful protestors for themselves.
“I think the news and even some YouTube creators are incredibly biased,” Wallace said. “News stations and YouTubers can take the footage and later edit them to fit their personal agenda.”
Similarly, Celina Juarez, a 21-year-old restaurant employee in Los Angeles, felt that news outlets weren’t focusing on what mattered. Juarez lives with her grandparents and didn’t want to risk spreading the coronavirus to them, since the elderly are at high risk.
“I feel that the news is showing more of the looting and less of the police brutality against peaceful protest when based on every Livestream I’ve tuned into, it’s really the opposite,” Juarez said in a Twitter DM.
While the protests have been associated with looting and rioting, multiple videos show black protestors shutting down white agitators attempting to graffiti storefronts and steal merchandise. When the protests began in Minneapolis in response to the death of George Floyd, a black man who was killed by a white police officer, Juarez and Wallace felt that news coverage focused on the looting rather than law enforcement escalating violence against peaceful protestors.
In addition to presenting a clearer picture of the protests in support of Black Lives Matter, live streams also provide crucial information for those who attend.
Elijah Daniel, a YouTuber with 568,000 subscribers and 446,000 Instagram followers, attended numerous protests in Los Angeles last week. He’s also been broadcasting the protests on Instagram Live, where tens of thousands of viewers watched police tear gas gatherings, shoot rubber bullets into crowds, and arrest peaceful protestors who were out after Los Angeles’ controversial curfews.
I watched Daniel’s protest Livestream last week because I had several friends who were also marching in Hollywood. It seemed peaceful from wherever Daniel was marching, but the chants of “No justice, no peace” were broken up by panicked comments warning viewers that police were tear-gassing protestors a few blocks ahead. Madison Beer, another influencer who’s been actively attending protests and was marching ahead of Daniel, tweeted that cops were beginning to block in protestors well before curfew.
TEAR GAS ON SUNSET AND VINE 51.7K 6:07 AM – Jun 2, 2020
4,278 people are talking about this
cops are zoning in on argyle. everyone is blocked in. all cars and people are trapped in from both sides.
2,357 people are talking about this
As soon as I read the Livestream comments, I called everyone I knew at the protests to warn them. One narrowly avoided the gas and rubber bullets, which law enforcement began deploying just minutes after he decided to take side streets out of Hollywood.
This weekend, I attended the massive candlelight vigil for George Floyd and other black victims of police brutality, which took place only blocks from where police had arrested thousands of peaceful protestors the week before. During the drive over, I watched the Livestream broadcasted by Black Lives Matter Los Angeles to keep tabs on police presence. Watching the protests live is a matter of safety.
“I know it’s easy to watch a video on the internet, but to watch it in real-time is on a whole other level.”
Daniel’s viewers are also using the Livestream to open up conversations about police brutality and privilege with their families. Claire-Louise, a 21-year-old customer service agent in Belfast, Ireland, can’t attend protests in Ireland because there aren’t any close enough to be accessible. She’s been showing Daniel’s live streams, as well as other screen recorded live streams, to her family members who she claims are “a bit backward in their mindset.”
“I know it’s easy to watch a video on the internet, but to watch it in real-time is on a whole other level,” Claire-Louise said in a Twitter DM. “I get happy when I see the peacefulness but I get angry and anxious when I see the brutality and just blatant racism.”
Influencers and celebrities continue to fall out of public favor through this period of civil unrest. From posting well-intentioned but ill-informed black squares to their Instagram accounts to getting arrested for looting, as Jake Paul did, celebrity culture is cracking. But those who use their platforms for activism, as Elijah Daniel and Halsey have, are inspiring a generation of viewers to join the Black Lives Matter movement.
“Even though I can’t actually be there, it at least makes me feel like I am,” Wallace said. “Seeing how many people are at the protests, plus thinking about how many people are watching live streams, makes me think that in time something may actually happen.”
